Examination of images in Australian standardised writing assessments: a case for recognising social and cultural disadvantage

Authors

Katherine Bates, University of WollongongFollow

RIS ID

113099

Publication Details

Bates, K. (2018). Examination of images in Australian standardised writing assessments: a case for recognising social and cultural disadvantage. Social Semiotics, 28 (2), 257-285.

Abstract

From a socio-cultural perspective, individuals interpret meaning from images depending on multiple factors including life experience, values, attitudes, interests and background. As such, engagement with, preference for and interpretation of images differs amongst viewers. From this premise, it seems unlikely that one visual writing assessment prompt will effectively suit all participants. This paper offers new research into the use of image in large-scale referenced-based narrative writing assessments over a 10-year period in Australia reporting on phase one of a comparative case study. Findings identify changes in prompt design and content each year, with significant changes accompanying the introduction of the National Writing Assessment in 2008. Conclusions drawn from the analysis state that while image is a powerful communicator of meaning, providing visual representations in national assessment plan for literacy and numeracy may privilege some participants over others, and in doing so, impact on student outcomes and contribute to stratifying disadvantage.