Suppression of dissent in science

Authors

Brian Martin, University of WollongongFollow

RIS ID

74829

Publication Details

Martin, B. (1999). Suppression of dissent in science. Research in Social Problems and Public Policy, 7 105-135.

Link to publisher version (URL)

Suppression of dissent in science

Abstract

There are numerous documented cases of attacks on dissident scientists, yet there is no established body of literature or standard theoretical frameworks for dealing with this phenomenon. Cases in three contentious areas - pesticides, fluoridation, and nuclear power - are used to illustrate processes and patterns of suppression. The evidence in these areas shows the possibilities and difficulties in drawing links between suppression and corporate, professional, and state power, respectively. Studies of suppression can provide a convenient probe into the exercise of power in science and more generally into the dynamics of expertise and legitimacy in a technological society.